When I saw this article in Ad Age, I had just one reaction. Ugh, aren't we over this yet?
Crowdsourcing ads makes about as much sense as do-it-yourself heart surgery.
The agency loses because these campaigns devalue the very product they're selling: strategic creativity.
99.99% of all participants lose because, of the thousands who will spend hours and hours generating ideas and producing materials without compensation to enter in the competition, only one will be chosen.
The client loses because instead of having the agency spend time uncovering insights and developing ideas to build the Chevy brand and sell cars, they're knee deep in consumer-generated garbage trying to find a few gems.
I have only one question about the campaign:
How does having aspiring film makers create a commercial on the Oscars lead to higher sales?
If the answer includes the words engagement, community, conversation, advertainment or any of the thousands of other social media buzzwords, you might want to start working on a new idea.